Why a person or party to a case appeals. There will always be someone who feels successful. Someone is also leaving with the sense of having lost. Do you have the option to appeal the decision if you don’t like it? The Michigan Court of Appeals is one option. You have access to the appellate court. If there are grounds for an appeal, you may use it. A Friend of the Court’s appeal to a judge is not the same as an appeal in the appellate court. For a hearing, you can go to a Friend of the Court. After a specific number of days, you can request another opportunity if you’re unhappy with the outcome. The court will set a date for a De Novo hearing. What do you need to know about family law appeals in Michigan?
Click here to watch the video on What You Need to Know About Family Law Appeals
That’s not what the Court of Appeals (COA) does. It is not a De Novo tribunal that hears cases from scratch and issues a fresh decision. The COA allows you to challenge certain decisions made by the lower court on the application of the law. You thought the lower court handled some evidence improperly when it heard it. Or, the court made an admission that you believe was improper. Perhaps something that ought to have been admitted was rejected by the court. These are legal issues.
You can argue any of these points. What result can you expect if you appeal these matters? The appellate court can choose from various options. The COA may agree with you. Although the lower court erred, it determined that the error was inconsequential. The error itself didn’t substantially affect the outcome. The appellate court may or may not agree with you in all your arguments. You may lose your appeal if the appellate court fully upholds the judgment.
What do you mean by filing an appeal?
An “appeal” is a request to have a higher court modify or overturn a decision made by a lower court. A higher court reviews the entire matter if you file an appeal. You cannot have your trial redone in front of a higher court after filing an appeal. No new information is offered, and no witnesses are contacted. Instead, an appeal requests that a higher court review the transcripts of your hearing, the evidence (documents, exhibits) that was admitted at your hearing(s), the judge’s ruling and order, any relevant law (state statutes and/or case law) that you want the appeals court to consider, and your justification for why the lower court erred clearly or the judge overstepped their legal authority. Common family law issues you can appeal:
- Making insufficient factual findings
- Failure to draw sufficient legal conclusions
- Child support does not conform to the typical range of awards.
- Support for a spouse does not fall within the typical range of awards.
- The decision was made without carefully examining the law or the evidence and was based only on legal conclusions.
What is the Friend of the Court and De Novo hearings?
The judge cannot do all the many tasks in the judicial process. They have court clerks to help them with most tasks. There is another division helping judges in the enforcement of court orders in family law cases. This division also helps in arranging court hearings for all parties in family law cases.
Friend of the Court
The Circuit Court Family Division’s enforcement and inquiry branch is called the Friend of the Court (FOC). The FOC is a statutorily established entity. The FOC supports the court’s domestic relations docket. The FOC supports the court by resolving domestic disputes. Its role is to uphold the court’s decisions for support, custody, and parenting time. Court personnel work for the FOC. With over 38,000 cases, the FOC’s responsibilities include:
- Enforcing child support orders;
- Enforcing custody and parenting time orders;
- Reviewing the amount of child support under the Michigan Child Support Formula;
- Looking into custody and parenting time issues. Making recommendations to the Court; and
- Offering mediation services for custody and parenting time issues.
The FOC helps parties needing an agreement about custody, parenting time, or child support. The FOC can turn an agreement into a binding court order. Fill out a Consent Order Request Form. As instructed on the form, send it to the FOC. A meeting will be scheduled.
De Novo hearings
De novo hearings are ones that are held “from the beginning” and apply to hearings and recommendations made by the FOC in divorce or custody cases in Michigan. The FOC works with judges to attempt and settle contentious custody, parenting time, and support issues in family law cases. However, since FOC referees are not elected officials, they are only able to provide suggestions to judges rather than render a decision.
Either party may request a de novo hearing or a hearing “from the beginning” with the trial court judge following the FOC’s suggestion. A section of the Michigan Compilation of Laws codifies this right. A FOC referee may appear, behave, and dress like a judge, but they are not. Instead, FOC referees assist the trial court in formulating recommendations that, absent a party’s request for a de novo hearing, constitute a final order.
What is an appellate court?
The intermediate appellate court for the state is the Court of Appeals or COA. Both the Michigan Supreme Court and trial courts are served by it. It is regarded as an error-correcting court. It evaluates matters from the trial courts. Decisions from appellate courts are most often published. It means that they become a part of the state’s broader body of laws. It is used as a precedent in subsequent cases. You therefore require a skilled family law appeals attorney in Michigan. Making an appeal does not guarantee that it will be accepted. Any appellate court must accept an appeal for review, so how it is presented is crucial.
You wonder if you have other options after disagreeing with the judge’s decision. The chief circuit court judge can appoint a domestic relations referee. It is permitted by Michigan law. In a domestic relations case, this referee weighs motions. The question of Michigan child custody is regarded as a domestic relations issue. A parent is entitled to request that the judge overturn the referee’s recommendations. Decisions by a family division judge in Michigan may be challenged before the COA. All parties in a divorce or custody dispute always have the option of an appeal.
What issues can you bring to the Michigan Court of Appeals?
When is it most acceptable to appeal? Filing an appeal does not grant any of the parties a second chance. It is not intended for those who merely object to the trial court’s ruling. Appellants must provide evidence that the law was applied improperly. It had an impact on whether the trial court’s procedures were fair and just. The following is a list of typical grounds for appeal:
Errors of law
You have a much better chance of succeeding on appeal if the judge makes a legal error. The trial court’s judgment may be overturned by the Court of Appeals. At this point, the court erred by applying the incorrect legal standard. A knowledgeable appellate attorney is recommended if you wish to determine whether such a mistake was made in your case. Look for one with experience in family law appeals.
Abuse of discretion
In situations where there has been an abuse of discretion, appeals are frequently lodged. Judges’ authority can be abused. They might choose poorly or incorrectly. Neither the law nor the evidence supports it. A witness’ suitability to provide expert testimony is determined by the court. It’s possible that a witness or exhibit won’t be able to make a statement. The choices you make here will significantly affect how your case turns out. Judges have a lot of latitude in their decision-making. If there had been a significant abuse of discretion, the appeal would be successful.
Insufficient evidence
Your appellate attorney must demonstrate that the evidence is insufficient. The evidence can be insufficient or unreliable. Pure speculation was employed as the only kind of evidence in the lower court hearings. More supposition than conclusion was involved. Your attorney can demonstrate that a claim is unsupported by any proof. In court, the opposing party was unable to present any witnesses. The opposing party did not offer any written or tangible evidence to back up their assertions. The evidence may have been perceived erroneously by the court. Your lawyer can demonstrate that you presented a stronger argument throughout the hearings. more proof than the opponent.
Procedural errors
The grounds for an appeal may include procedural errors. An oversight made by the court while it was considering your case is known as a procedural error. As a result of the mistake, the proceedings were no longer impartial. There are various ways that procedural errors can appear. Courts are capable of making procedural mistakes by disregarding the correct standards of proof. When neither party is given a fair chance to be heard by the court. Another method may be if the court didn’t base its judgments on the evidence.
The Michigan COA does not allow you to re-litigate your case. In other words, you give up the chance to call witnesses. witnesses that you chose not to present at the lower court hearings. There is no chance for you to show any documents. evidence that you neglected to provide to the circuit court. You are not given the chance by the COA to provide any new evidence. You are essentially left with the testimony that was presented in circuit court, good and bad. The COA only makes an argument if the judge in the lower court implemented Michigan law improperly.
How do you file an appeal?
It takes a lot of effort to complete the COA appeal process. Quite a bit of money, your time, and effort as well. The cost can suddenly rise. You’ll spend money on paperwork. You still have to gather the lower court’s transcripts of the hearings. Your Michigan family law appeal lawyer needs those transcripts to represent you before the COA. Without a copy of the lower court’s transcripts, the COA cannot even review the case. Hundreds of pages make up this kind of transcript. It will take some time for the circuit court reporter to complete all transcripts. The appeal process can take a while to arrive at a decision or opinion. A straightforward appeal includes the following steps:
File a Notice of Appeal
Sending in a Notice of Appeal is the first step in the appeals procedure. Within 30 days after the judgment’s entry, submit the notice to the court. You should have a “legal brief” prepared by your attorney.
Get the appeal brief ready
The arguments in favor of the appeal are presented in a written document called the appeal brief. The appeal brief must be written as the next action. Calling a legal brief “brief” is a little deceptive because there’s nothing brief about the document. Your attorney is unable to merely inform the COA that the circuit court judge erred in law. The case needs to be researched by your attorney. In order to prove your point, provide the COA with relevant legislative and case law citations. The COA examines both your brief and the brief of the opposing side. After the Notice of Appeal has been filed, the appeal brief must be submitted to the appellate court within 40 days.
File Reply Brief
Within 20 days following the appeal brief’s submission, the opposing party may submit a reply brief.
Oral argument
The parties present oral arguments before the appellate court. After the submission of the reply brief, the COA schedules oral arguments for 60 to 90 days later. Before a panel of three judges, your counsel will present your case. Usually, Lansing or Detroit will host this.
The Appellate Court’s decision
Following the hearing of oral arguments, the appeal court will render a judgment. The COA makes a decision after reviewing the written briefs. The decision of the appellate court is final and enforceable against the parties.
Does the outcome of an appeal justify the time and resources invested in it? Is it deserving of your focus and feelings? Is it not time to consider moving on? Start thinking about life after divorce. You still need to think about your children. They have already been through so much. Your marriage was dissolved in family court by your divorce judgment. You experienced suffering, uncertainty, and fear not just for yourself but also for your children.
What is the likelihood your appeal will prevail in the Court of Appeals?
It’s hard to say. Depends on what issues you raise and the basis of why you raised them in the first place. On matters of fact and credibility, the COA accords the trial court with a tremendous deal of deference. In other words, unless there is an obvious mistake, the COA will not overturn the trial court’s factual findings. However, the court will do a de novo assessment of legal concerns, which involves a new set of eyes. A reversal or remand may be appropriate if the trial court applied or construed the law wrongly. Even if the COA considers the issues, the majority of appeals do not lead to a change in the trial court’s decision.
If you manage the appeal yourself, the odds are not in your favor. A non-represented party’s appeal has considerably more of a likelihood of being rejected. The COA reports that more than half of right-of-return appeals are dismissed because of procedural mistakes in situations when the appellant was not aided by counsel. More than 90% of applications for leave to appeal are denied. If your appeal is denied or dismissed, you won’t get your money back. That adds to more frustration on top of the long wait for the decision.
You will always have the option to appeal. There is a price for that right? You have already paid a price for ending your marriage. By appealing, consider the expense of going through the agonizing rollercoaster ride again. Consider the possibility of moving forward and improving your life and the lives of your children. Filing an appeal is challenging. If you don’t have an excellent lawyer and unlimited funds, the odds are usually against you. Living under a final judgment is typically more economical. It is a less annoying choice. Allow your attorney to go over the requirements for an appeal with you. Inquire as to the appeals procedure.
Find out more about the requirements for success. More than 50 percent of appeals are turned down. You only have a 50/50 chance of getting it right, according to statistics. There is only a 50% probability that things will turn out well. If you are not well-represented by an excellent lawyer, your odds are significantly lower.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel today for more advice on Family Law!
Goldman & Associates Law Firm is here to with information about Child Custody and Divorce in the State of Michigan.
At Goldman & Associates Law Firm there’s always a sympathetic ear ready to listen.
Book your complimentary case evaluation with our leading attorneys.
(248) 590-6600 CALL/TEXT if you need legal assistance.