A judge might make a choice about your child that makes you sad or mad. You may want to say no to the judge’s choice. But you need to know what happens if you do. This guide tells you why you must listen to the judge. It also tells you what to do if you think the judge was wrong. You can see a video about this topic to learn more.
What Does It Mean to Say No to a Judge’s Plan?
Not Following the Rules: A judge’s plan is a rule you have to follow. To say no to the plan means you do not do what the judge said. This could mean you do not let your child go with the other parent. This is a very big deal.
Making Your Own Rules: Some parents think they can make their own rules. They may feel they are right and the judge is wrong. But the court does not see it that way. The court sees it as breaking the law.
Ways a Parent Might Say No:
- They do not bring the child for the trade-off.
- They keep the child for more time than they are allowed.
- They tell the child not to go with the other parent.
What the Judge Wants You to Do:
- Follow the time-sharing plan with no mistakes.
- Talk to the other parent in a calm way.
- Ask the court for changes in the right way.
A Short Story: One father was mad that the mother got to have the child. He told his child to run from the mom’s car at a stop light. The dad was waiting there to take the child. They were caught. The dad got in a lot of trouble.
Can You Get in Trouble for Breaking the Rules?
Yes, You Will Get in Trouble: The question is not if you can say no. The question is if you can say no and not get in trouble. You will get in trouble. The court has rules, and breaking them leads to bad results for you.
The Judge Has a Lot of Power: A judge can make sure you follow the rules. They can make new plans that punish you for not listening. They want to make sure the child is safe. They do not like it when parents make their own rules.
Types of Trouble You Can Get In:
- You may have to pay money to the court.
- The judge can make you pay for the other parent’s lawyer.
- You may have to go to special classes for parents.
More Big Problems You Can Have:
- You could lose time with your child.
- You may only see your child when someone is watching you.
- In bad cases, you could be sent to jail.
A Short Story: A mother did not let the father see his kids. It was the father’s weekend. The father told his lawyer, and they told the judge. The judge told the mother she must follow the rule. The judge also gave the father an extra weekend with the kids.
What Bad Things Can Happen to Your Time with Your Child?
Losing Your Rights as a Parent: This is the worst thing that can happen. If you keep breaking the rules, a judge can say you cannot be a parent anymore. This would mean you are not the child’s legal parent. This can last forever.
Time with a Watcher: A judge can order your time with your child to be watched. This means someone must be in the room with you and your child. You have to pay this person to be there. This costs a lot of money and is very hard to do.
Why Does This Happen?:
- The court’s number one job is to keep the child safe.
- Breaking rules shows you may not care about the child’s safety.
- It makes the judge think you will not follow other rules.
How This Hurts Your Child:
- It puts the child in the middle of fights.
- It can make the child feel scared.
- It can break the child’s trust in you.
A Short Story: The dad who tried to take his son had to have a watcher. He could only see his son if this person was in the room. The dad did not have the money to pay the watcher’s fee. Because of this, he almost never saw his son again.
If You Cannot Say No, What Can You Do?
Use the Court System: The court system is for both parents. If you are not happy, you must use the court’s rules to ask for a change. Trying to fix things on your own will not help. It will only make things worse.
Follow the Plan for Now: You must follow the plan the judge made, even if you do not like it. This shows the judge that you can follow rules. This makes you look good when you ask for a change. Our Michigan Child Custody Attorneys can help you with this. Good Steps You Can Take:
- File a paper that asks the judge to look at the case again.
- File a paper if you think the judge made a mistake with the law.
- Ask for a change if something new has happened.
How to Get Ready for These Steps:
- Write down everything that happens.
- Talk to a good lawyer about what you can do.
- Find the proof you need to show why you need a change.
A Short Story: A mother thought the father was not a safe driver. She did not keep the child from him. Instead, she filed a paper with the court. She showed the judge the father’s driving tickets. The judge then said the father could not drive with the child for a while.
Why Is Good Proof So Important?
A Judge Needs Proof, Not Stories: A judge will not change a child’s life just because you say so. You must have real proof that what you say is true. Your feelings and opinions are not proof. Proof is something that shows a fact.
What Is Good Proof?: Good proof is something real you can show the judge. It is not just your side of the story. It can be a photo. It can be a school report. It can be a text from the other parent. It must be something that shows what you are saying is true.
Things That Are Not Good Proof:
- Texts where you say mean things to the other parent.
- Stories from your friends or new partner.
- Saying you just have a “bad feeling.”
Things That Are Good Proof:
- School reports that show a child is doing bad.
- Messages where the other parent says they did something wrong.
- Papers from the police or a doctor.
A Short Story: A dad wanted to have his kids more. He said the mom’s house was not clean. He did not just say it. He took pictures of the mess. He showed the pictures to the judge. This was good proof that helped him.
What if You Do Not Have Good Proof?
A Hard Thing to Hear: If you feel you should have the kids but have no proof, then maybe you are wrong. This is very hard for parents to hear. But a judge will not take your word for it. You must show them why you are the better choice for the child.
No Proof Can Mean a Shared Plan: When no one can prove they are better, a judge often shares the time. This means both parents get the child for about half the time. If there is no proof of a problem, a judge will think both parents are good enough. A case like this can be a contested divorce that ends this way.
What a Judge May Be Thinking:
- Both parents seem good for the child.
- The parents’ fight is not about the child.
- A child should have both parents in their life.
What This Means for You:
- You must find a way to work with the other parent.
- Be the best parent you can be on your time.
- Stop fighting and think about the child.
A Short Story: Two parents both wanted the child all the time. They both said bad things about each other. But they had no proof. The judge said they would share the child 50/50. The judge told them to get along for their child.
How Can a Lawyer Help You?
Lawyers Know the Rules: A good lawyer knows what a judge needs to see. They are experts in the rules of proof. They can tell you what to look for. They can tell you what is not useful. You must listen to your lawyer.
They Help You Stay on Track: A good lawyer will tell you to talk about what is best for the child. They will tell you not to waste time on your hurt feelings. You can get help and learn How to Change Child Custody in Michigan the right way.
What a Lawyer Does for You:
- They tell you what proof you need.
- They file the right papers for you.
- They speak for you to the judge.
What You Must Do for Your Lawyer:
- Give them all the facts they ask for.
- Tell them the truth about everything.
- Do not try to hide things from them.
A Short Story: A client came to us and was sure she would win. She had a list of things she did not like. We told her a list is not proof. At first, she was sad. But she listened and got the proof we told her to get. This made her case much better.
What Is Most Important to the Judge?
The Child Is Number One: The judge’s main job is to do what is best for the child. It is not about making parents happy. Every choice is about keeping the child safe and well. Your case must be about the child.
It Is Not About Your Mad Feelings: You might feel the other parent was mean to you. You may not like them. But a judge will not give you the child just because you are mad. You must show how the other parent’s actions are bad for the child.
Things That Matter to a Judge:
- Who can give the child a good, safe home.
- The love between the child and each parent.
- The health of each parent.
Things That Do Not Matter to a Judge:
- Who wanted to end the marriage.
- That one parent has more money.
- That you do not like who the other parent is dating.
A Short Story: A dad was mad that the mom left him. He told the judge she was a bad person. The judge told the dad that the case was not about their old problems. It was about the child. The dad had to show proof that she was a bad parent, not a bad wife.
What Is a Parent Kidnapping Their Own Child?
This Is a Very Bad Crime: Not returning a child is bad. But taking a child and hiding them is much worse. This is called parental kidnapping. It is a crime. It can mean you lose your child for good and go to jail.
This Is Not a Way to Win: Some parents think this is a way to get what they want. They think if they hide the child, the court will give up. This is not true. The police will look for you. The results will be very bad. You should know What Happens If a Parent Kidnaps Their Own Child before thinking of this.
What Happens if You Do This:
- You will probably go to jail.
- You will lose all your rights to your child.
- The other parent will get an order to keep you away.
Why You Should Never Do This:
- It is very scary for your child.
- It shows the court you are not a safe parent.
- It is a problem that will mess up your whole life.
A Short Story: A mother lost her case. She was scared. She took the child to a new state and did not tell anyone. The dad called the police. They found her a week later. She was put in jail. The dad got full rights to the child.
Why Is a Lawyer Your Best Choice?
They Know the Way: Fights over kids are hard. It is like walking in a dark woods with no map. A lawyer is a guide with a map and a light. They know the safe path to take. If you do it alone, you can get lost and get hurt.
They Can Speak for You: It is hard to talk to a judge when you are full of feeling. A lawyer can speak for you in a calm, smart way. They can show your proof to the judge. They can do this without letting feelings get in the way. Our Top Rated Michigan Family Law Attorneys can be your guide.
Good Things About Having a Lawyer:
- You get advice from someone who knows the law.
- You do not make bad mistakes.
- You have a better chance to get what you want.
Bad Things About Not Having a Lawyer:
- You may not file the right papers.
- You may miss your dates with the court.
- You may say the wrong thing to the judge.
A Short Story: A father tried to fight for his son by himself. He did not know what to show the judge. He just told the judge he loved his son. The mom had a lawyer. Her lawyer showed proof. The dad lost because he was not ready.
More to Know A Chain of Bad Events: A bad choice is like knocking over the first block in a line. Once you break a court rule, bad things start to happen. The other parent files a paper. The judge gets mad. You lose time with your child. You have to pay money. It is hard to stop this chain of events.
There Will Be a Winner and a Loser: In court, someone often wins and someone often loses. You cannot be sure you will win. You have to be ready to lose. Making a plan to take the child if you lose is a plan to go to jail. You have to accept the judge’s choice.
Frequently Asked Questions:
1. What should I do first if I get a child plan I do not like?
First, follow the plan the judge made. Then, call a lawyer right away to talk about what to do next.
2. Can a child say they do not want to go with a parent?
A judge might listen to what a child wants, but the child cannot say no. The parent must make sure the child goes.
3. How much does a watcher for visits cost?
The cost can be from $30 to $50 each time you see your child. The parent who is being watched has to pay for it.
4. What does it mean to appeal?
To appeal is to ask a higher court to check the judge’s choice. You do this if you think the judge made a mistake in the law.
5. Can my text messages be used as proof?
Yes, text messages can be used as proof. Be careful, because your own texts can be used to hurt your case.
6. Does it matter if my lawyer is a man or a woman?
No, it does not matter at all. What matters is if the lawyer is good at their job and knows the law.
7. What if we agree to a change without the court?
You should still get the new plan in writing. Then you must ask a judge to sign it. If you do not, the old plan is still the rule.
8. How long does it take to change a child plan?
It can take a few weeks or many months. It depends on how busy the court is and if the other parent fights the change.
9. Can I lose my child just for being mad?
No, just being mad is not a reason to lose your child. But if being mad makes you break rules, then it can cause big problems.
10. What does “not enough proof” mean?
It means you did not show the judge enough to prove your case. A judge needs to see real proof, not just stories.
11. What if I do not have money for a lawyer?
You can look for a group called legal aid. They may help you for free or for less money. Some lawyers also let you pay over time.
12. Does a judge have to pick one parent to win?
No, a judge does not have to pick a winner. If there is no strong proof for either side, a judge will often make a shared plan.
If you have a child plan from a judge that you do not like, you need a new plan that follows the law. Trying to fix things your own way will only lead to more trouble. It could hurt the time you have with your child for good.
We want you to call us for help. Our team is here to listen to you. We can give you the help you need.
Phone: (248) 590-6600 (You can call or text us)
Free Talk: Set up a free talk with our team.
Website: Go to ChooseGoldman.com to learn more.