Divorce often goes through a property buyout. How is property buyout done? Is it the only option available to spouses in going about property distribution?
Click here to watch the video on How Is Property Buyout Calculated During Divorce
Even before you can count anything, assess its value, or confirm if it’s a marital asset, you have to know what they are.
To know what to include in the marital property inventory, you need to understand what constitutes marital property and separate property.
Informative Words You Need To Know Before Buyout
Before you even go to the whole process you call buyout, there’s certain concepts or keywords, spouses need to walk through to start considering what they need to include in the talk about marital assets.
Marital Assets
Marital assets in the context of divorce have been extensively discussed on this website. Any assets accumulated during the marriage are regarded as divisible marital property. Property that is susceptible to equitable distribution may include things like real estate, vehicles, bank accounts, investments, and company interests.
Be mindful that this applies to assets acquired during the marriage by either spouse, even if they aren’t acquired until after a divorce decree. For instance, even if you file for divorce or you are now truly divorced, before the bonus or commission is paid out, the bonus will be regarded as marital property if you earn it while you are married. It really makes no difference which spouse actually earns the asset.
Let’s assume only one spouse’s wages during the marriage are associated with a savings or retirement account. The savings or retirement account is still regarded as marital property by the law.
You might ask, what about the other assets?
The other assets you’re referring to are those currently not within the definition of marital assets.
You’re referring to separate assets.
Separate Assets
Now those assets earned prior to marriage or through inheritance are regarded as the parties’ separate property. They are typically not divided during a divorce.
If you receive a financial inheritance from your parents while you are married, it remains your own property. A present and any property you brought into the marriage are treated the same way.
There are instances however, demonstrating this may not always be true.
When spouses mix their separate property with their marital property, an exception occurs. Therefore, it’s possible a court will determine everything in that account is marital property if you receive money as a gift or as an inheritance, and deposited it in a joint bank account where money is coming in and going out during the marriage.
If the other spouse ever makes a contribution to the separate property, that is another exemption. In that case, the spouse who contributed might be eligible for a share of the asset.
Consider a scenario in which one spouse owned a home before getting married and never gave the other spouse an interest in it. However, during their marriage, the couple split the cost of home improvements. After that, the non-owner spouse can be qualified for a share of the gain in the home’s worth that can be attributed to the modifications.
The date of purchase or acquisition is a crucial detail to establish when evaluating if something is separate property.
As an illustration, if one partner wished to claim an automobile as separate property, they would need to show evidence of the date they purchased the car as well as the date of their marriage. The car qualifies as a party’s separate property as long as it was acquired and paid for prior to the date of their marriage, and no significant upgrades were made or incurred during the marriage.
You Need To Know Debts Then The Bottom Line
You cannot approximate the true net worth of your marital assets if you don’t factor in the debts the marriage has accumulated. Modern life makes it almost impossible for marriage to last without debts when you have to acquire what you need like education, home, and equity for business.
Usually, the debt associated with a piece of property is assumed by the recipient. The property may occasionally remain in the possession of the individual who can afford to pay the obligation associated with it.
Debts incurred by one spouse before marriage are considered separate debts. All debts incurred during a marriage are, in general, considered marital debts. Whoever made the purchase and whose credit card was used are irrelevant.
To this rule, there are some exceptions.
Gambling debts, extramarital affair debts, and debts for restitution in legal proceedings are typically not considered marital debt. To get your education, you probably got a loan.
If student loans taken out during a marriage were exclusively utilized for one spouse’s schooling, they are considered distinct debt. However, student loans can be considered marital debt if they were utilized to maintain the family.
Here’s a caveat:
Your creditors are not subject to the jurisdiction of the judge overseeing your divorce. You owe money to your creditors. Each debt may be assigned to either you or your spouse by your divorce judgment. Creditors might still view debts that are in both of your names as joint debt, though.
It is crucial that the divorce judgment includes a list of any debts that are in both of your names. So that the other spouse can have the judge enforce the order if the individual ordered to pay the debt doesn’t. You can file a motion requesting the judge to require your spouse to pay you back if you wind up paying a debt that was assigned to your spouse.
Revealing Is Eye-Opening, You Need To Know Your Assets, What It’s Worth
The value of the property must be known by the court in order to properly distribute it in a fair and equitable manner. Generally, it can be quite simple with some assets, like a bank account.
With some assets, you’ll usually need to consult an expert, such as a business or real estate appraiser, while dealing with others like assessing the value of a professional practice.
A house you acquired together is supposedly fairly easy to see as a marital asset and peg a dollar value to it. You both decide to sell it and the court orders the proceeds divided equally 50-50 then both of you go your merry (or probably not so merry) ways.
The truth is in most cases it can be a bit complicated.
The marital house can be difficult to divide. The couple deciding to sell the home and divide the proceeds is the simplest solution to the problem. If only one spouse chooses to go that way, they must ask the judge to make the order.
There is never an assurance the judge will act in that way, though.
Minor children present can also make things more difficult. The parent who has primary residential custody of the children may frequently desire to remain in the marital residence in order to prevent uprooting the children.
If the couple is unable to agree on what should be done with the house, the court will make the decision, once again based on what they believe is most equitable for all parties.
If dealing with the house is just as interesting, consider having a business or a professional practice (add the fact you’re working with your spouse in the practice).
Being amiable can occasionally feel elusive or unreachable when one spouse has worked for the family business for a long time. Perhaps the person’s siblings own stock in the company or their parents are still running it.
Every additional party in the ownership mix, has a unique set of emotions and ideas, which can lead to extremely challenging circumstances.
When a company appears to be worth a lot of money, one spouse may try to convince the other that it actually has negative equity.
Businesses commonly require specialized equipment, which typically depreciates over time. Expensive technology depreciates even faster. Arguments that equipment is still used in regular business operations even though it has no documented value are common in divorce disputes.
Another common point of contention is retirement.
When retirement accounts are being divided before their pay-out period, evaluating them might be particularly difficult. In those circumstances, you’ll need to figure out the account’s current worth, which almost certainly calls for an actuary’s help.
What is the common practice of determining the value of your assets?
The help of professionals who specialized in the valuation of assets can aid in determining the value of marital assets. Doing a valuation of a business enterprise can be daunting if one of the assets is company ownership.
Before beginning an appraisal, business valuation professionals must establish a standard of worth. A set of assumed circumstances under which the company will be appraised constitutes a standard of value. There are two generally accepted standards for business valuations in divorce cases: fair market value and fair value.
It is merely guessing to divide assets when one does not actually know their entire value. There are three main approaches to business valuation that are frequently used in Michigan divorce disputes.
- Value in books. This method does not take into account intrinsic worth, such as brand recognition, and instead only looks at a company’s assets less depreciation.
- Market price. This is a rough estimate of the price an investor may pay to buy the company. This strategy typically yields a greater corporate valuation.
- Going-concern assessment. This method contains intrinsic value and assigns a value to the company based on its ongoing operations.
The approaches above in knowing your assets and determining of value merely helps in determining a number to talk about when dividing assets. In reality, the emotional investment of both parties in this asset may be incalculable. These valuation approaches are the closest you can get to the concept of fair distribution.
Important Opportunities Better Than A Simple Buyout Offer
You don’t really have to choose buyout to resolve your asset distribution. There are other options you can take. Talk to your attorney about this. Your attorney might just have another way to approach the question of fair distribution.
In the case with the marital home. There could be so much drama and emotion invested in it. You may have to be creative in choosing an alternative to a buyout.
There are several methods to approach this.
The spouse who wants to stay in the home may be able to purchase the other spouse’s equity if there are sufficient joint assets available. To balance things out, one spouse gets to keep the house while the other gets to keep more of the other assets. Refinancing the house, if possible, and using the money from the refinance to pay the other spouse is another way for a spouse to purchase the other’s interest.
A very typical alternative is for the couple to decide to maintain the house in both names while one of them lives there, but only until a specific date, such when the youngest child starts or finishes college. The house will then be sold, and the couple will split the money. The spouse who is currently residing in the home is normally in charge of covering its expenses at this time.
As to the retirement, maybe another approach might make sense to both parties.
The portion of a pension or retirement plan that was acquired during a marriage is typically considered marital property. The non-employee spouse is entitled to a portion of their spouse’s pension or retirement plan in the event of divorce.
Sometimes parties agree to preserve their respective pensions or retirement plans and not divide them. Giving the non-employee spouse additional assets equal to half of the retirement benefit accumulated by their spouse during the marriage is another option.
In the end, both spouses must come to an agreement even before they appear before a judge. Even better if they get to do it before they talk to their respective lawyers.
The judge will make the decision if you and your spouse are unable to agree on how to divide your possessions. According to Michigan law, courts must divide property fairly.
Generally speaking, fair means everyone gets to receive roughly half of everything. But in other circumstances, a judge might rule that dividing marital property differently is reasonable.
If one spouse was more responsible for the breakdown of the marriage or if one spouse required more property, your property may be distributed unequally. In some cases, one spouse gains greater marital assets while also accruing more marital debt.
You need to work with your lawyer to define what your goals are in the process.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel today for more advice on Family Law!
Goldman & Associates Law Firm is here to with information about Child Custody and Divorce in the State of Michigan.